Advocates to Fight Washington Team's Name, Despite Court Ruling in Similar Case

Asian-American band win top court case over offensive trademark

When the Asian-American dance-rock band the Slants tried to trademark their name, they were denied by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.

The Redskins made similar arguments after the trademark office ruled in 2014 that the name offends American Indians and canceled the team's trademark.

A lower court agreed with Tam and the Supreme Court on Monday upheld that decision, saying that the "disparagement clause" of the Lanham Act unconstitutionally infringed on free speech rights. It offends a bedrock First Amendment principle: "Speech may not be banned on the ground that it expresses ideas that offend". Now it is believed the team will be able to register and protect their name. Fundamentally, the First Amendment prevents the government from punishing or suppressing speech based on disapproval of the ideas or perspectives the speech conveys.

"W$3 e're beyond humbled and thrilled to have won this case at the Supreme Court", wrote band frontman Simon Tam, who filed the original lawsuit against the Patent and Trademark Office. As the trademark office's manual puts it, an examiner determines whether or not the mark would be found disparaging by a "substantial composite, although not necessarily a majority, of the referenced group".

Said Tam, "The establishment of an Asian American band was a political act in of itself, even though we never considered ourselves as a political group". He expects the team to write a letter citing the Supreme Court decision and the 4th Circuit to overturn the district court decision that upheld cancellation of the team's federal trademark registrations.

This contradicts the inflammatory myths being circulated that the term came from the practice of paying a bounty for Indians (using a "red skin" in reference to a bloody, red scalp of a Native American).

After UP and Maharashtra, Punjab government announces farm loan waiver
BJP governments led by Yogi Adityanath and Devendra Fadnavis are in power in Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra, respectively. Deputy chief minister Sukhbir Singh Badal said on Tuesday that the decision will be implemented from July 1.

St. John's University intellectual property law center director Jeremy Sheff said while the Supreme Court has essentially shut the door on legal challenges to the Redskins name, "there can still be social pressure brought to bear". Issuing a license of sorts, specifically for the Redskins trademark, isn't the speech of the government.

"Now, you well know people say things that you strongly disagree with".

But Amanda Blackhorse, a Navajo woman who has been the lead plaintiff in a yearslong legal fight against the team's name, said the fight is not over, adding that years of litigation have found that "the term is offensive".

Some of this is simply too much of a mess to dissect here, such as the idea that holders of an "offensive" trademark could somehow chill protest by suing people who "criticize the use of such marks".

Blackhorse called the decision "disheartening" after 11 years of litigation.

Importantly, nothing stopped Tam from exclusively using The Slants for the name of his band and from stopping others from using The Slants, should he choose to do so, by asserting a claim for unfair competition or false designation of origin under 15 U.S.C. § 1125. They were unanimous in rejecting the argument that federal trademarks are the government's own speech and thus immune from First Amendment scrutiny of any kind.

Related News:

  • Fed raises rates, unveils cuts to bond holdings in sign of confidence

    Fed raises rates, unveils cuts to bond holdings in sign of confidence

    Shanghai's Composite index edged 0.1 per cent lower to 3,128.29 and the S&P ASX 200 in Australia tumbled 1.1 per cent to 5,770.90. They forecast US economic growth of 2.2 percent in 2017, an increase from the previous projection in March .
    Diego Costa resigned to Chelsea exit but keen on rejoining Atletico Madrid

    Diego Costa resigned to Chelsea exit but keen on rejoining Atletico Madrid

    He added on rumours of a return to his roots in Brazil at Palmeiras: "To be honest, now, I find it very hard ". He declared: "I'm a Chelsea player but they do not want me there".

    Canadian National Railway Company (CNR) PT Raised to C$115.00

    Finally, Wells Fargo & Company assumed coverage on shares of Canadian National Railway Company in a report on Monday, March 13th. Finally, AGF Investments Inc. raised its stake in shares of Canadian Pacific Railway Limited by 66.4% in the first quarter.
  • Andhra CM sacks ex-Chief Secretary for FB posts

    Andhra CM sacks ex-Chief Secretary for FB posts

    Rao has been the first Chief Secretary of residual state of Andhra Pradesh after the bifurcation of the United Andhra. Rao was the first Chairman of the corporation constituted for the welfare of Brahmins with Rs 100 crore corpus fund.
    Sridevi AND Anil Kapoor to return for

    Sridevi AND Anil Kapoor to return for "Mr India" sequel?

    Sridevi was last seen in Tamil film Puli . "But to the world, it became a reason to misunderstand me", Sridevi said. The source also revealed that Sridevi and Anil Kapoor wouldn't be the only important actors working in the sequel.

    The Helix Energy Solutions Group (HLX) Receiving Positive News Coverage, Report Finds

    The stock of Helix Energy Solutions Group Inc (NYSE:HLX) has "Market Perform" rating given on Tuesday, December 29 by Cowen & Co. Green Plains Inc. (GPRE) have shown a high EPS growth of -22.80% in the last 5 years and has earnings rose of 52.70% yoy.
  • Wozniacki and Mladenovic in quarter-final action

    However, the youngster was able to seize the advantage in set two, moving a double-break up at 5-2 before play was suspended. Bacsinszky - seeded 30th - won the crucial ninth game to go 5-4 up and then successfully held serve to win the first set.
    Three Workers Injured in Crane Accident at Astoria Construction Site

    Three Workers Injured in Crane Accident at Astoria Construction Site

    Dozens of FDNY firefighters were at the renovation site in Astoria on Tuesday evening as they worked to rescue a trapped person. A roof collapsed in Queens on Tuesday leaving two people trapped inside prompting NY firefighters to jump into action.
    Lockheed signs pact with Tata to make F-16 planes in India

    Lockheed signs pact with Tata to make F-16 planes in India

    The announcement comes days before Prime Minister Narendra Modi travels to Washington for a meeting with Donald Trump on June 26. The F-16 Block 70 is the newest and most technologically advanced F-16 ever offered.
  • Fosun lifts bid for Fabergé owner Gemfields to £256m

    However, the committee believes it is "materially more attractive than the unsolicited all-share, nil-premium offer from Pallinghurst".

    Terri Sewell votes against bill aimed at reversing Dodd-Frank financial regulations

    Hensarling, Texas Republican. "With this bill, Members are being asked to again trust the very people who brought us to this financial crisis", Crist said.

    Analysts Watch Patterson-UTI Energy, Inc. (NASDAQ:PTEN) And Issue New Targets

    Sandler Capital Management holds 0.34% of its portfolio in Patterson-UTI Energy, Inc. 5,307,708 shares of the stock traded hands. The Firm owns and operates a fleet of land drilling rigs and a fleet of pressure pumping equipment in the United States.


Most liked

Spicer hasn't talked Russia meddling with Trump
Trump didn't take questions in his media appearance with the Panamanian President Monday. Mike Dubke, who had been in that job for less than three months, resigned in May.

Disney characters sign 'I love you' to deaf boy
An adorable video of a little boy getting the best surprise on a trip to Disneyland has been posted online and went viral. It's truly a handsome sight to behold - a wonderful Disneyland sign language surprise.

Points to Know As Georgia House Race Heads to Voters
While Trump won the district by only 1 percent in November, Georgia's 6th congressional district usually favors Republicans. Ms Handel, 55, spent Monday campaigning across the district, and received support from a Donald Trump tweet on Tuesday.

Sixers Officially Move Up to No. 1 in Trade With Celtics
I'm a pretty good shot blocker for a point guard, so I think helping them with that, everything would pretty much help with that. Otherwise, the Celtics will have a choice between the better 2019 first-round pick between Sacramento or Philadelphia.

Los Angeles Lights Bat-Signal For Late Actor Adam West
Without the success of the original Batman series, it is hard to imagine where television or superhero content would be today. In this real life setting, it was Garcetti who fired up the spotlight, alongside Los Angeles police Chief Charlie Beck.

Confederations Cup : Ronaldo's Portugal take on hosts Russian Federation
It's the first time Portugal has played in this tournament so it's a privilege for all of us. 'It's the new rule. Salceio slips, and Ronaldo taps the ball across for Quaresma to cut past the "keeper for an easy finish".

Boeing, Airbus compete for orders at air show
Boeing , the world's No. 1 plane maker, said Tuesday that passenger traffic is poised to grow 4.7% over the next two decades. Delivery to airlines like United Airlines, British Airways and launch customer Singapore Airlines will begin next year.

Trump calls Warmbier's death a 'total disgrace'; public service set
The North Korean government has vowed to develop a nuclear-tipped intercontinental missile capable of hitting the USA mainland. Or maybe North Korea concealed his medical condition for so long in the hopes that he'd recover.

Paddy Barnes: I'd love to see Conor McGregor knock out Floyd Mayweather
The request was for an event to be broadcast on Showtime, which had an exclusive agreement with Mayweather. The 12-round match is slated for 154 pounds, or boxing's super welterweight division.

Investor's Watch List: Petroleo Brasileiro SA - Petrobras (PBR)
Over the long run, the price of a stock will normally go up in lock step with its earnings (assuming the P/E ratio is constant). Zweig-Dimenna Associates Llc decreased Petroleo Brasileiro Sa Petro ( PBR ) stake by 12.78% reported in 2016Q4 SEC filing.

RAAF halts military flights over Syria amid escalating 'potential threats' from Russian Federation
Moscow has condemned the US downing of the Syrian government fighter jet after it dropped bombs nears USA partner forces. It also issued what appeared a threat to target US coalition aircraft flying west of the Euphrates River.

Gagnon Securities LLC Raises Stake in Chipotle Mexican Grill, Inc. (CMG)
RI acquired a new position in shares of Chipotle Mexican Grill during the first quarter valued at approximately $203,000. The firm owned 2,534 shares of the restaurant operator's stock after buying an additional 299 shares during the period.

Google's Project Fi Makes it Easy to Split the Bill
Inside the app the user will head to the Account Billing section - and there will be settings for group repay. Family plans are often times cheaper than buying a single line plan from one of the U.S. carriers.

Ryan promises to overhaul tax code this year despite hurdles
Ryan's planned remarks, however, do touch on the idea of the border adjustment tax, which he favors . Notably, Ryan spoke about "transformational tax reform", while Pence talked about "tax cuts".

ADL urges hate crime probe in slaying of US Muslim teen
Another vigil, in Hassanen's hometown of Reston, Virginia , is planned for Wednesday. "Somebody took her life for no reason". South Lakes High School Principal Kim Retzer said in a letter Tuesday that she visited with Nabra's family a day earlier.