'Selfie' monkey Naruto can not sue for copyright, U.S. court rules

No, A Monkey Can't Copyright His Selfies, Federal Appeals Court Rules

"But now, in the wake of PETA's proposed dismissal, Naruto is left without an advocate, his supposed "friend" having abandoned Naruto's substantive claims in what appears to be an effort to prevent the publication of a decision adverse to PETA's institutional interests", the court said.

PETA didn't seem particularly close to Naruto even though it sued Slater as a "next friend" of the monkey, the court noted.

This case dates back to 2011 when British nature photographer was on a shoot in the Tangkoko reserve in Indonesia, and a crested macaque monkey named Naruto got hold of his camera and started snapping pictures of itself.

The court has also ruled Slater is entitled to compensation for his legal feels, with the district court now working out how much he should get.

Jeff Kerr, general counsel for Peta, said the group was reviewing the opinion and had not decided yet whether it would appeal.

The 53-year-old said: 'I was making no money from photography, which is a hard industry to begin with'.

Nigerian troops intercept Boko Haram wives
During the operation, troops encountered elements of Boko Haram insurgents who were withdrawing hastily from the camp. Texas Chukwu , the Director, Army Public Relations, one terrorist was killed while several others fled.

PETA and Mr Slater reached a deal in September outside of court where he agreed to donate 25% of the revenue he receives from the selfie to charities that protect crested macaques.

The income that he receives from the selfie is "embarrassingly low", he added. To make matters worse, PETA didn't seem to have a lot invested in the case, since Slater pointed out they mixed up the monkeys. PETA sued Slater and self-publishing company Blurb in 2015, arguing the monkey owned the copyright to the photos and proposing it administer all proceeds for the benefit of the monkey. But the 9th Circuit still made a decision to rule in the important case.

An appeals court in NY past year rejected a case involving two chimpanzees, saying there was no legal precedent for the animals being considered people, and their cognitive capabilities didn't mean they could be held legally accountable for their actions.

The 9th Circuit's opinion - joined by Judge Eduardo C. Robreno, with Judge N.R. Smith concurring in part - rested on three main points: whether PETA's relationship with Naruto was significant enough to allow the organization to be his next friend, whether animals can legally bring a case in federal court, and whether they have standing under the Copyright Act.

Kerr said Monday the 9th Circuit ruling would not affect the settlement.

Related News:

  • Prince Harry & Meghan Markle Emerge After Kate Middleton Gives Birth

    Prince Harry & Meghan Markle Emerge After Kate Middleton Gives Birth

    Saturday night's event is only Meghan's second official engagement with The Queen. HELLO! Canada magazine is available for your tablet and smartphone.
    Throw All Romaine Away, Washing Won't Do the Trick — CDC

    Throw All Romaine Away, Washing Won't Do the Trick — CDC

    The source of these cases has not been identified, but the AHS does not believe they are linked to the initial outbreak. Anyone with these symptoms should see a doctor immediately and report the infection to local health departments.
    Illegal order, says Congress

    Illegal order, says Congress

    This motion does not deserve to be admitted", said Naidu. "Proved misbehaviour comes after the inquiry". Rajya Sabha Chairman and Vice President M Venkaiah Naidu at his residence in New Delhi , Monday.
  • European Union  investigators to investigate Apple's bid for Shazam

    European Union investigators to investigate Apple's bid for Shazam

    It's alleged that Apple could get unfair access to commercially sensitive information about users of rival music services. Apple announced the deal in December to help it better compete with industry leader Spotify.
    Guentzel scored four goals as Penguins eliminate Flyers

    Guentzel scored four goals as Penguins eliminate Flyers

    Flyers goaltender Michal Neuvirth struggled and gave up seven goals on 27 shots before an empty-netter served as the eighth tally. Couturier missed Game 4 with the right-knee injury but had enough strength and playoff toughness to fight through the pain.
    The Top 14 of 'American Idol' Perform Live on Television

    The Top 14 of 'American Idol' Perform Live on Television

    The way the judges were talking, it seemed like they'd already made up their minds about cutting Donaldson. A relieved Barrett commented to host Ryan Seacrest that she "felt like I got the message across".
  • Flight Records Contradict Trump's Alibi for Mysterious Moscow Visit in 2013

    Flight Records Contradict Trump's Alibi for Mysterious Moscow Visit in 2013

    In fact, Trump arrived in Moscow, where he attended the Miss Universe pageant, which he owned at the time, on a Friday. The plane arrived in Moscow at 6:15 a.m on a Friday and departed Russian Federation at 3:58 a.m. on Sunday.
    Leafs 3, Bruins 1: Talk about a forced Game 7

    Leafs 3, Bruins 1: Talk about a forced Game 7

    Game 7 goes Wednesday night in Boston. "We can't expect to score five goals every game, so we can't be giving up four [goals]". The Leafs were able to hold off the Bruins trio thanks to Andersen, who took up where he left off in Game 5.
    Armenian opposition leader says will hold talks with acting PM on Wednesday

    Armenian opposition leader says will hold talks with acting PM on Wednesday

    The politician added that if the "street" was against him as prime minister, he would step down. Ultimately, Sargsyan stepped down as prime minister on April 23.
  • 49ers GM says Reuben Foster's future hinges on case

    49ers GM says Reuben Foster's future hinges on case

    The 49ers started their offseason program on April 16, but Foster is not participating . The San Francisco won't cut linebacker Reuben Foster until the legal process plays out.
    Follow the White House press briefing

    Follow the White House press briefing

    United States president Donald Trump has accepted an invitation of the North Korean leader Kim Jong-un for a summit meeting. Neither South Korea nor the United States has diplomatic relations with North Korea.
    Where is 2018 NFL Draft?

    Where is 2018 NFL Draft?

    That probably won't be the case in the first round this year despite the fact he floated the idea last week. Philadelphia has no pick in round two or three, and the Eagles don't pick till the end of round four.

Most liked

Caravan of Migrants Reaches US Border
She warned that the United States will enforce the law through prosecution of illegal border crossers. Hundreds of migrants arrive at the Mexican border seeking asylum in the U.S.

Kansas Students Participate in Walkout to Protest Gun Violence
He grew up in Parkland but never attended the school, though he knows several students who go there but were not hurt in the shooting .

Death penalty to rapists:Delhi HC asks GoI about POCSO ordinance
Under the new changes those who are found guilty of raping a child under the age 12 will automatically face the death penalty . Lawyer Vrinda Grover said the provision of fast track courts in the Ordinance is misleading as there are not enough judges.

Rain showers develop tonight; Wet Wednesday with temps in the mid-50s
More rain expected Sunday night through Monday morning with lows in the mid 50s and highs staying in the low 60's. High clouds continue to build across our area now and skies remain mostly cloudy through the evening and night.

PSL promise justice to perpetrators of fan violence
In a video, fans could be seen kicking and beating the guard with chairs and other unidentified objects. One fan kicked him in the upper chest, a kick that collapsed her to the ground.

Saudi Warplanes Attack Wedding Party in NW Yemen, Killing Dozens
This is the latest in a series of Saudi airstrikes that have killed thousands of civilians over three years of war in Yemen. This breaking news story is being updated and more details will be published shortly.

Alexis Sanchez lifts lid on 'very difficult' Manchester United spell
I demand a lot from myself every match, every day, I am happy to win today and for the team'. Have your say in the comments section below.

Houston police: Woman sets car on fire with children inside
A mother in Houston was arrested Sunday after allegedly setting fire to a auto while inside with her three children, police said. She tried to run away, but tripped and officers arrested her after a short struggle, police said.

Google parent firm Alphabet reports strong financial results
Alphabet made some changes in its financial reporting this quarter, including removing Nest from its " Other Bets " revenues. In the three months to 31 March Alphabet delivered profit of $9.4bn (£6.7bn), up from $5.4bn in the same quarter past year .

Dispose of unwanted prescriptions at Saturday drop-off
DEA remains committed to supporting public safety in American Indian and Alaska Native communities. This initiative addresses a vital public safety and public health issue.

Atletico Madrid's Diego Costa unlikely vs. Arsenal in Europa League first leg
Arsenal midfielder Mohamed Elneny has been ruled out of the Gunners' Europa League semi-final tie against Atletico Madrid . Atletico Madrid will be without full-back Juanfran for their trip to north London to take on Arsenal on Thursday night .

Thousands Of Jubilant Napoli Fans Welcome Team After Juve Win
Massimiliano Allegri's side face a trickier run-in, as they will face Inter Milan and Roma. Roma and Lazio both have 67 points from 34 games with Roma ahead on head-to-head clashes.

Mexico and European Union reach new trade deal
Mexico is in ongoing talks with the United States and Canada on overhauling the North American Free Trade Agreement . Among them were manchego, parmesan and gruyere, but Mexican producers will be able to continue using those names.

Without a seat at the table, customs union membership is worthless
Downing Street has insisted she is still promoting both plans in negotiations with Brussels and does not have a preferred option. Mrs May's spokesman said BBC reports that she was contemplating calling a confidence vote were an "absolute mystery to me".

Horse race bet with William Hill
How to place a bet To place your wager/bet, all you need is to provide the appropriate information to the ticket writer. Simply you just have to pay £1horse bet and you can easily watch the live horse racing broadcast on your device.