Supreme Court Tosses Gay-Bias Finding Against Wedding-Cake Baker

HIGH STAKES The U.S. Supreme Court could decide some blockbuster cases today as the term nears its end. AP file

The court took issue with a Colorado commission and its treatment of Phillips.

The court held that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission showed hostility toward the baker based on his religious beliefs.

Justice Clarence Thomas, who did not join Kennedy's opinion, wrote a separate concurrence suggesting that the baker's case precisely reflected conflict between gay marriage and free speech.

Baker Jack Phillips had argued that cake-baking is constitutionally protected free speech and that sanctioning him for refusing to bake for a same-sex marriage violated his constitutional right to free exercise of religion. "Importantly, the Court reaffirmed that there is no general constitutional exemption from civil rights laws just because a person has a religious or philosophical objection to them".

"I tried to respectfully apologize that I couldn't create this cake", he said.

"The Colorado Civil Rights Commission's consideration of this case was inconsistent with the State's obligation of religious neutrality", Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in the majority opinion, referring to the state authority that sided with the couple after they filed a complaint.

Alliance Defending Freedom attorney Kristen Waggoner represented Phillips in oral arguments, noting that the court "has never compelled artistic expression, and doing so here would lead to less civility, diversity, and freedom for everyone, no matter their views on marriage".

"The Court's precedents make clear that the baker, in his capacity as the owner of a business serving the public, might have his right to the free exercise of religion limited by generally applicable laws", he wrote. The Arizona-based group brought suits on a behalf of a wedding photographer in New Mexico, a florist in Washington state and the Colorado baker whose case reached the Supreme Court. "But only, as the Court rightly says, if the State's decisions are not infected by religious hostility or bias". The justices voted 7-2 that the commission violated Phillips' rights under the First Amendment.

The Unemployment Rate Is The Lowest It's Been Since April 2000
The issue this raises is whether jobs that would normally be held by people with little or no skill are indeed filled. Almost 15 percent of what he calls "job stayers" saw no increase in wages in the past 12 months.

"What matters is that Phillips would not provide a good or service to a same-sex couple that he would provide to a heterosexual couple", Ginsburg said.

He appealed the state's decision, but lost in the Colorado courts.

"The government, consistent with the Constitution's guarantee of free exercise, can not impose regulations that are hostile to the religious beliefs of affected citizens and can not act in a manner that passes judgment upon or presupposes the illegitimacy of religious beliefs and practices", the opinion continued.

Colorado is one of 22 states whose civil rights laws require businesses that are open to the public to serve all customers on an equal basis and without regard to their sexual orientation.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented from the court's ruling, in an opinion joined only by Justice Sonia Sotomayor.

A completely different case that trolled those who wanted to force the baker to make the cake ended up being relevant to the decision.

Intriguingly, the decision can be understood as a hint that President Donald Trump's Muslim travel ban may be struck down later this month, as the travel ban can be read as expressing hostility to Muslims.

Related News:



Most liked

What will Apple announce at WWDC? iOS 12, MacBook, iPhone SE2 rumours
He also said that Swift, the programming language Apple developed and uses for its apps, is also picking up some strong momentum. There are rumours going around that Apple will reveal a portable speaker that works with Siri , but we couldn't confirm that.

Trump energy plan would prop up failing coal and nuclear plants
Although the memo describes a planned Energy Department directive, there was no indication President Donald Trump had signed off on the action nor when any order might be issued.

Tested negative for Nipah, 36-year-old Kerala woman dies under observation
In another precautionary measure, all nine staff members at Balussery taluk hospital in Kozhikode district have been given leave. Besides, officials have asked those people who made contact with the two, who died due to Nipah, to get in touch with the cell.

Phoenix killings of psychiatrist, 2 women linked
A man suspected of killing at least four people in Scottsdale, Arizona is dead, law enforcement sources told ABC News. Police say one of the women managed to walk to an intersection to seek help despite a gunshot wound to her head.

Mattis takes hard line on China in Singapore speech
Gen He added: "We see any other country that tries to make noise about this as interfering in our internal affairs". A more assertive Pentagon approach already appears to have started.

North Korea replaces top three military officials
Yonhap reported that Kim Yong Chol had transited Beijing on Monday on his way back to Pyongyang from the United States. Ri Myong-su, 84, chief of the general staff of the Korean People's Army, has been replaced by Ri Yong-gil, his deputy.

Get ready for an above-average hurricane season in 2018
In an average hurricane season, 12 storms are named and six become hurricanes, of which three reach at least category three. Last year's historic hurricane season claimed lives across the Gulf and caused almost 300 billion dollars in damage.

Antoine Griezmann confirms future will be resolved before World Cup
France start their World Cup with a Group C clash against Australia on June 16 in Kazan, with Griezmann expected to spearhead Didier Deschamps' attack.

Barcelona lock up Samuel Umtiti with new five-year contract
But in the face of transfer speculation the France worldwide has opted to commit himself to the Blaugrana until 2023. Umtiti will formally sign the five-year deal on Monday, before Barca hold a news conference.

Visa: 'Service disruption' blocking Europe transactions
Credit card company Visa is experiencing a service disruption across Europe which is preventing transactions being processed. Bank of Ireland said it was aware of the disruptions but that people can withdraw cash from ATMs.

Facebook pulls 'Trending' to try new approaches to news
Trending represents on average under 1.5% of clicks to news distributers. It's the company's latest move to reform how it shows users news.

NBA Finals 2018: Stephen Curry breaks 3-point record
If Cleveland Cavaliers fans needed another reason to hate Golden State Warriors forward Draymond Green , they got it on Saturday. Through two games of the 2018 Finals, Curry is making a pretty serious case that he should check off that box.

Is Microsoft acquiring GitHub?
The acquisition comes after nine months of uncertainty for GitHub, seeing that it hasn't been able to find a new CEO in that time. Many corporations, including Microsoft and Alphabet Inc.'s Google, use GitHub to store their corporate code and to collaborate.

Volcano eruption in Central America kills six
The Volcán de Fuego has spewed a stream of lava into a nearby village and sent a column of smoke and ash into the sky. A woman who was covered in ash told the Diario de Centroamerica that lava had poured through corn fields.

Alexander Zverev ends Grand Slam hoodoo against top-50 players
The second seed recovered to win from two-sets-to-one down for a third consecutive match at the French Open on Sunday. Open champion in 2017, blew past Anett Kontaveit of Estonia 6-2, 6-0 in just 52 minutes on Court Philippe Chatrier.