Too soon to create gene-edited babies, say scientists

He Jiankui

He Jiankui, an associate professor at Southern University of Science and Technology in Shenzhen, addressed about 700 people attending the Human Genome Editing Summit at the University of Hong Kong on Wednesday.

The China government in retaliation to worldwide scientific furore has ordered a "thorough investigation" into the project and has stopped further work.

The girls had their genes edited so they could resist being infected with HIV, he said.

The presidents of the US National Academy of Sciences and the US National Academy of Medicine said the work "clearly demonstrates the need for us to develop more specific standards and principles that can be agreed upon by the worldwide scientific community". The leader of the conference called the experiment "irresponsible" and evidence that the scientific community had failed to regulate itself to prevent premature efforts to alter DNA. It's believed that altering DNA before or during conception is risky because the changes could be inherited or harm other genes. He made the stunning revelation that a mother had given birth to Lulu and Nana, twin girls whose genes had been edited to make them resistant to HIV. "We don't know. He said he confirmed that essentially they'd done the hormone test for whether or not the woman was pregnant".

CRISPR-Cas9 allows scientists to essentially cut and paste DNA, raising hope of genetic fixes for disease.

"Three scientists were disciplined, they were dismissed from their positions, and they could not apply for grants over a certain period of time, so [He's case] may be similar to this", Qiu told Al Jazeera.

What he did share at the conference on Hong Kong has led some to question the success and the safety of his experiment, though it's hard to really determine what happened or how well it worked without a full set of data from He.

Too soon to create gene-edited babies, say scientists
Too soon to create gene-edited babies, say scientists

There is no independent confirmation of what Mr He says he did.

Several groups have already expressed their criticism and opinion about the issue, including the conference where He claimed to have edited the genes of twins. "I personally don't think it was medically necessary".

Scores of scientists - including numerous top genetics experts gathered in Hong Kong - have called He's conduct unethical. HIV is not an appropriate candidate because there are already safe ways to prevent transmission, and if contracted it can be kept under control with medications, researchers said.

"If the modifications are verified, the procedure was irresponsible and failed to conform with global norms", the statement reads.

Before He's talk, Dr. George Daley, Harvard Medical School's dean and one of the conference organizers, warned against a backlash to gene editing because of He's experiment.

"I think all of us are wondering about the role of Michael Deem", Collins told STAT, "who by his description was present at the consenting of couples that took part in this gene-editing enterprise".

Robin Lovell-Badge, a professor of genetics and embryology at the Francis Crick Institute in London who moderated the session, asked a question that he said was on many attendees' minds. Investigations were opened into He's work by China's Southern University of Science and Technology, which has said the university was not informed of the experiment.

Former US President George Bush dies at age 94, family spokesman says
He also battled Parkinson's disease and was hospitalized in the past year for a blood infection, low blood pressure and fatigue. They added: "Our thoughts are with the entire Bush family tonight - and all who were inspired by George and Barbara's example".

Related News:



Most liked

NASA Chooses Nine Companies to Bid on Flying to Moon
What? Is NASA going to the moon? Deep Space Systems , which has worked on Orion, Juno, and other NASA missions is also in the mix. NASA believes the first missions could head for the moon as soon as next year, and it already has some payloads in mind.

Watch NASA’s Mars InSight landing live right here
NASA officials say it will take two to three months for the main instruments to be deployed and put into operation. The spacecraft will be landing on Elysium Planitia , a large volcanic plain stretching north of Mars' equator.

Jeep Gladiator Photos, Specs & Key Details
A JeepGladiatorForum user called Jeremi has posted new photos and more detailed specs of the Wrangler-based JT truck . There's the new rear seats which can be folded upwards to reveal a hidden storage bin that can hold several items.

Instagram now lets you share stories with close friends only
If a user adds you to their friend list, you'll see a green ring around their Story ring, same with you adding a story. Tap the "Close Friends List" option in the side menu on the right side of the app to create or add people to the list.

Teaser of Ariana Grande's "thank u, next"
Same goes when the movie Mean Girls came out in 2004, we felt like our high school lives were put on the big screen. Ariana Grande's 'thank u, next' music video is quickly shaping up to be one of the cultural events of the year.

Rajinikanth's '2.0' opens to phenomenal reception in Telugu states
NV Prasad said, "2.0 is running successfully in Telugu states and the movie collected Rs 21.5 crore gross on its first day". Keeping in mind the fact that it's a dubbed film + advance bookings opened very late, the biz is STRONG.

Theresa May left RED-FACED after SEVENTH Brexit resignation deals DEVASTATING blow
He also called for Article 50 to be extended to explore other options amid growing calls for the prime minister to go back to Brussels and strike another agreement.

Clinton Accuses Trump of Helping to Cover-up Khashoggi Murder
The sanctions will freeze the assets of those individuals in Canada, said the country's foreign minister in a statement. President Donald Trump during the summit, but he hinted they might have occasion for talks on the sidelines.

'Battle' over as Trudeau, Trump, Pena Nieto sign 'new NAFTA'
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau did not refer to the new agreement as USMCA on Friday, as U.S. President Donald Trump has called it, but instead simply referred to it as the "new NAFTA".

Honduran Murderer in Migrant Caravan Caught Illegally Crossing into U.S.
A self-admitted MS-13 gang member also traveling with the caravan was arrested Saturday . One had been previously deported, authorities said.

Oil drops below $50 for first time in a year
Its citizens continue to endure power outages and inadequate access to clean water. Analysts had predicted that inventories would go up by only 1 million barrels.

Jurgen Klopp reacts angrily to question on Liverpool's 'overrun' midfield
They were different games in the past, it was clear that Everton would be very passive, that is not the case now. Nobody has to tell you players want to be a part of these derbies before they join the club.

US welcomes efforts by India, Pak to increase people-to-people contact
Responding to Pakistan's invitation, Modi's foreign minister, Sushma Swaraj rejected the idea of talks. Imran Khan said India needs to look at Kashmir differently and not as a territorial issue.

Video surfaces of Chiefs' Kareem Hunt attacking woman
The NFL did not take any action against Hunt after the altercation was reported to police in February, according to the Star. However, Hunt's friends told police that the woman went off when she was asked to leave and called Kareem the n-word.

A Third of Migrant Caravan Participants Have Health Issues Including Lice, Tuberculosis
The fate of the 42 immigrants remains unclear but Customs and Border Protection said they will face deportation. Asylum seekers are often released in the USA pending the outcome of their cases in immigration court.